Ten years after the UK voted to leave the European Union, the legal consequences for international injury victims remain profound. The political debate has moved on – or perhaps it is coming full circle, depending on whom you speak to. But for seriously injured victims and bereaved families, the loss of European civil justice cooperation continues to affect access to justice in practical, costly and sometimes life-changing ways.

One of the quieter and more technical legal consequences of the referendum on 23 June 2016 which led to Brexit was the removal of the UK from a mature European framework governing jurisdiction and the recognition and enforcement of judgments in civil and commercial matters. For injury victims, that framework determined where a claim could be brought, how quickly compensation could be secured and whether a judgment would be enforceable without expensive satellite litigation.

After the end of the Brexit transition period on 31 December 2020, the UK no longer participates in the Brussels regime. Its application to re-accede to the Lugano Convention has not been approved by the EU. In its place, practitioners must navigate a patchwork of domestic rules in the country where the individual claimant might ultimately have to enforce a judgment. That may be manageable for sophisticated commercial parties with negotiated contracts, jurisdiction clauses and resources to litigate procedural disputes. It is far less satisfactory for an individual injured abroad or for a family pursuing a fatal accident claim after the death of a loved one.

Injury claims do not usually fit neatly within the Hague Convention framework on jurisdiction and enforcement. Hague 2005 is concerned with exclusive choice of court agreements, but excludes employment and consumer contracts, so it is rarely relevant to an accident victim. Hague 2019, which has a broader scope and came into force for the UK on 1 July 2025, is a welcome development but not a complete answer. It contains exclusions and limitations that are significant in personal injury and fatal accident cases, including issues relating to carriage of passengers and goods, interim measures and the basis on which judgments obtained through the tort gateway qualify for recognition and enforcement.

This has real consequences. A British tourist seriously injured in an EU member state may wish to bring proceedings in England and Wales, where they live, receive treatment and require long-term care. The English court may be willing to accept jurisdiction in appropriate cases under domestic rules, including where continuing loss is suffered here. If the defendant or insurer is based in the EU, the claimant may ultimately need to enforce an English judgment abroad. Without a comprehensive reciprocal regime, recognition and enforcement must be assessed country by country, increasing uncertainty, delay and cost.

 

Claim dynamics

That uncertainty can alter the dynamics of a claim from the outset. It can affect where proceedings are issued, whether interim payments are realistically available, how defendants and insurers approach settlement and whether additional expert evidence is required on foreign procedure or enforcement. For claimants with catastrophic injuries, these are not peripheral matters. Challenges in securing compensation can delay rehabilitation, adaptations to accommodation, specialist equipment and care packages. In fatal accident cases, uncertainty over jurisdiction and enforcement can compound the distress and financial insecurity faced by bereaved families.

It is true that we no longer have the same level of freedom of movement within the EU; however, the reality is that people continue to travel, work, study and buy services across Europe. Individuals require a civil justice framework that reflects this reality, providing unequivocal reciprocity on the enforcement of judgments and jurisdiction provisions that protect weaker parties.

Ten years on from the referendum, the impact of Brexit on injury victims remains a live access-to-justice problem. The 2026 review of the UK-EU Trade and Cooperation Agreement offers an opportunity to address what was missed in 2020. If Lugano remains politically unattainable, the UK and EU should pursue a targeted bilateral arrangement protecting weaker parties in cross-border injury, consumer and employment disputes.

 


 

International injuries conference

Chris Deacon will be speaking on the topic of ‘Enforcing judgments across borders – practical routes to recovery’ at APIL’s international injuries conference on 27 November, at the London Marriott Regents Park Hotel and virtually.