The recent fire safety defects decision in Vivid Housing Ltd v Allianz Global Corporate & Specialty SE [2026] EWCA Civ 1389 gives important guidance to policyholders seeking cover for defects requiring a threat of ‘imminent’ damage. It emphasises the need to apply the test based on a reasonable assessment of the full facts, including the severity of the risk, rather than attaching an absolute or abstract temporal standard to the meaning of the word ‘imminent’. The judgment provides an important reference both for policyholders claiming for cladding and fire safety remediation costs, and more generally under latent defects policies.
Background facts
The claimant (Vivid) is the insured under a housing warranty insurance policy issued by Building LifePlans Ltd as coverholder under a binding authority granted by the defendant insurer (Allianz). The policy was issued in respect of a 72-flat development at Collins Place, Hampshire, of which Vivid owns the freehold.
The policy ran from 22 May 2008 to 21 May 2020. Just before the policy expired, on 19 May 2020, Vivid notified a claim concerning a number of fire safety defects, including combustible Rockpanel cladding, missing or defective cavity barriers, and combustible debris within building cavities. The claimant stated on the claim form that no urgent repairs were required and that it had implemented a waking watch and associated preventative measures. Additionally, a CBRE façade fire risk assessment assessed the use of Rockpanel and workmanship defects as “Important issues/Actions – Medium risk materials”, while the absence of compartmentation was categorised as “Critical issues/Action – High risk material”.
The policy provided cover where a defect caused, among other things, a threat of imminent destruction or physical damage requiring immediate remedial measures. Allianz sought summary judgment on the basis that the alleged fire-safety defects did not satisfy this requirement.
On 16 December 2025, the Technology and Construction Court rejected the defendant insurer’s (Allianz) application for summary judgment, holding that there was a real prospect that the insured could establish that the risk of fire-related damage was sufficiently serious and imminent to fall within the insurance policy. Allianz appealed that decision to the Court of Appeal, which was heard on 20 October 2026, with the judgment handed down on 3 November 2026
The meaning of “imminent” damage: the Court of Appeal’s approach
The key coverage issue concerned the meaning of “imminent” damage. Allianz submitted that “imminent” should be given its normal and ordinary meaning, contending that at first instance the judge construed the relevant clause in a way that failed to give any or any effective meaning to the word “imminent”.
The Court of Appeal treated the question of how close or immediate threatened physical damage must be before it can be described as “imminent” as a question of fact and degree, rather than imposing a rigid temporal test. Viewed objectively, is the threatened destruction or physical damage sufficiently likely to happen sufficiently soon? Therefore, the assessment does not turn on a fixed period within which the threatened damage must occur.
Fire safety defects may exist for a considerable period of time without the occurrence of a fire. Allianz’s proposed approach was that the relevant clause would respond to defects where the circumstances “made the ignition of fire imminent”. However, the court’s approach focused on the policy language and confirmed that it is the threatened destruction or damage that must be imminent, not necessarily the fire itself. It was therefore not necessary simply to ask whether a fire itself was “imminent”, but whether the defects gave rise to a threat of destruction or physical damage that was sufficiently likely to materialise sufficiently soon.
This judgment also demonstrates the importance of evidence surrounding the risk, showing that the assessment of imminence is not undertaken in the abstract. Lord Justice Stuart-Smith stated: “There is an obvious relationship between the severity of the risk and the urgency of proposed remedial repairs.” The seriousness of the risk was reflected in CBRE’s assessment categorising the absence of compartmentation as a critical, high-risk issue, from which Vivid took the remedial step of implementing a waking watch and other preventative measures. Essentially, steps taken because a risk is considered sufficiently serious to demand intervention may themselves provide evidence of the nature and urgency of that risk
The decision
Ultimately, Allianz’s appeal was dismissed, upholding the Technology and Construction Court’s refusal to grant summary judgment. It is important to note that the court did not finally determine that Vivid had established imminent damage. Rather, it held that Vivid had a real prospect of establishing at trial that the defects presented a sufficiently serious risk of fire, with a consequent threat of destruction or damage sufficiently soon, to satisfy the policy wording.
Analysis
While it remains to be seen whether Vivid will be able to demonstrate a threat of imminent destruction or damage on the facts, the Court of Appeal’s judgment helpfully resists a narrow construction of “imminent”, which would require damage to be virtually immediate before cover could respond. The test remains fact-sensitive and will depend upon the nature and severity of the defects, the likelihood and potential timing of damage, and the evidence available as to the seriousness of the risk. It is important to consider whether the evidence as a whole shows that the threatened damage is sufficiently likely to occur sufficiently soon.
Two practical takeaways for policyholders are therefore:
- Evidence is critical: policyholders should preserve contemporaneous evidence of the severity and urgency of the risk.
- Actions can support the coverage case: precautionary measures taken in response to a serious risk may themselves provide evidence of imminence, so the reasons for those measures should be clearly documented.