The Privy Council clarified the proper purpose rule in Grand View Private Trust Company Ltd v Wong [2022] UKPC 47 (“Grand View”). The Royal Court of Guernsey recently applied the substance of that rule in Murray Stewart v Suntera Private Wealth (Guernsey) Ltd and others [2026] GRC 040 (“Murray v Suntera”). In this article, Geoff Kertesz and Annabelle Davies examine the decision in Murray v Suntera.
The decision in Murray v Suntera illustrates the continuing significance of Grand View in determining the permissible use of trustee powers. In particular, the court held that trustees must exercise even broadly drafted powers for the purposes for which the settlor conferred them. The court may therefore declare a trustee’s exercise of power void even where the trustee acted in good faith and received no personal benefit.
The proper purpose rule in Grand View
In 2022, Stewarts, Baker McKenzie Taipei, and MJM Ltd (Bermuda), with Richard Wilson KC, James Weale KC and Charlotte Beynon of Serle Court, successfully represented the appellant, Tony Wang, before the Privy Council in Grand View. Further details can be found here: Privy Council provides clarity on proper scope of trustee powers.
Grand View concerned the transfer of all assets of the Global Resource Trust (“GRT”), a discretionary trust for members of the Wang family, to the Wang Family Trust (“WFT”), a purpose trust that conferred no benefit on the family members. The GRT trustee exercised powers in the trust deed that allowed it to add and exclude beneficiaries, adding the WFT trustee as a discretionary beneficiary and excluding all other beneficiaries (the GRT and WFT trustees were separate companies with common directors). The GRT trustee then transferred the entirety of the trust assets to the WFT and ensured that no family members could benefit.
The Privy Council held that the GRT trustee had exercised those powers for an improper purpose. Although the trust deed expressed the trustee’s powers broadly and permitted the steps taken, the settlor conferred those powers to further the interests of one or more of the GRT’s beneficiaries, not to deprive them all of any benefit. The Privy Council therefore held that the transfer was void.
Grand View applied in Guernsey: Murray v Suntera
This case concerned Suntera Private Wealth (Guernsey) Limited (“Suntera”), the professional trustee of two discretionary family trusts known collectively as the “Old Trusts”. Murray’s late father, Alistair, established the first, and Suntera established the second following Alistair’s death. In 2021, Suntera restructured the assets of the Old Trusts into three US foreign grantor trusts:
- The A Trust: established with US$15m, principally for Murray’s benefit,
- The B Trust: established with US$15m, principally for the benefit of Murray’s sister, Catherine, and
- The Future Gen Trust: established with the substantially larger balance of the assets for their mother, Helen, and future generations of the family.
Helen was the grantor of the A Trust, while Catherine was the grantor of the other two trusts. The grantors had extensive powers, including powers to direct income and revoke the relevant trusts, subject to third-party consent.
Catherine’s husband, David, played a central role in the restructuring, liaising closely with Suntera and influencing the design of the new trust structure and Suntera’s approach towards Murray. The court found that Suntera placed excessive weight on David’s views and allowed him to drive the restructuring without appropriate independent challenge.
Murray challenged the restructuring because it fundamentally altered his position under the Old Trusts. Before the restructuring, he held a discretionary interest in the substantially larger Old Trusts. Following the restructuring, his principal interest was in the US$15m A Trust, but Helen’s powers allowed her to remove its assets from his benefit if she chose to exercise them. Murray claimed, among other things, that Suntera had exercised its powers for an improper purpose.
The court’s application of Grand View
In considering Murray’s proper purpose challenge, the court expressly relied on the Privy Council’s approach in Grand View, together with the Supreme Court’s judgment in Eclairs Group Ltd v JKX Oil & Gas plc [2015] UKSC 71. It held that those authorities “should guide the proper purpose rule in [Guernsey]”.
Drawing on Grand View, the court explained that a trustee may breach the proper purpose rule even where the trustee derives no personal benefit and does not act in bad faith. The central question is whether the trustee exercised the power for a purpose for which the settlor conferred it.
Applying that analysis, the court found that the settlor’s objective intention was that the Old Trusts should operate as family trusts for the benefit of the named beneficiaries and his future issue. The objective purpose of the relevant powers was “to further the interests of the Beneficiaries of the Old Trusts”, and Suntera therefore had to exercise its powers in furtherance of that purpose.
By creating the three foreign grantor trusts, Suntera conferred powers on the grantors that could override the other terms of the trusts and extinguish them. The effect was to place the assets of the Old Trusts beyond Suntera’s fiduciary obligations to the beneficiaries and beyond the court’s supervisory jurisdiction. This left the beneficiaries in a “precarious and vulnerable position”, dependent on the goodwill of the grantors rather than any legally enforceable rights.
Applying Grand View, the court concluded that Suntera’s decision to create the foreign grantor trusts fundamentally undermined the structure and protection of the Old Trusts as discretionary trusts with a familial and dynastic character. Suntera had therefore exercised its powers for an improper purpose, and the court held that the exercises of power that effected the restructuring were void. In addition, the court found that Suntera had failed to exercise independent judgment, had effectively delegated its discretion to others, and had failed to consider relevant matters. These failures amounted to a breach of fiduciary duty, and Suntera was also found to have been grossly negligent in preparing the A Trust instrument.
Differences between Grand View and Murray v Suntera
The factual patterns of the two cases differed significantly, yet the same principles applied in substance. In Grand View, the trustee transferred all the assets of a discretionary family trust into a separate trust from which the beneficiaries could not benefit. In Murray v Suntera, the family beneficiaries formally remained within the new trust structure; however, the grantors had overriding powers capable of extinguishing their interests. The court considered this difference one of form rather than substance.
Murray v Suntera extends the principles established in Grand View. A trustee does not need to remove every beneficiary for the proper purpose rule to apply; the rule may also apply where the trustee creates overriding powers capable of defeating the beneficiaries’ interests.
Significance of Grand View
Murray v Suntera illustrates the continuing significance of Grand View. The court will examine the substance of trustee decisions rather than focus on whether the terms of the trust deed permit them. Trustees must therefore assess not only whether the trust deed formally permits a proposed restructuring, but also whether the resulting structure remains consistent with the purposes for which the settlor conferred the relevant powers.